Reviewed · MUSEUMS
Old Jail Museum Tour in St. Augustine
St. Augustine’s darkest address has a surprisingly lively tour. I like the real cell blocks and gallows most, along with the odd detail that the sheriff and his family lived directly above the prisoners. The main drawback is that the experience depends heavily on your guide, and a theatrical guide may not suit everyone.
For $18.09, you get a focused 30-minute look at one of the city’s more unusual historic sites. I also like the frequent departures, every 20 minutes from 9:00 a.m., though tours run first come, first served, so an online ticket does not reserve a particular departure.
In This Review
- Key points to know before you go
- Entering St. Augustine’s Old Jail
- Cell blocks, maximum security, and regular prisoners
- Sheriff Perry and the power behind the jail
- The sheriff’s quarters are part of the story
- A theatrical guide can make or break the visit
- Why the $18.09 admission can be worthwhile
- Timing, tickets, and a practical visit plan
- Who will enjoy this short history tour
- Should you book the Old Jail Museum?
- FAQ
- How long does the Old Jail Museum tour take?
- What are the Old Jail Museum’s hours?
- How often do tours depart?
- Can I reserve a specific tour time?
- Is parking available?
- What is the cancellation policy?
Key points to know before you go

- Eight executions took place here, including the 1908 hanging of Sim Jackson, who was convicted of murdering his wife with a straight razor.
- Sheriff Perry looms large in the story, both literally and figuratively. He was 6 feet 6 inches tall, weighed 300 pounds, and served St. Augustine during two periods between 1889 and 1919.
- The sheriff’s family lived upstairs, just steps from the cells, and used their kitchen to prepare meals for inmates.
- Guides often perform in character, adding jokes, role-play, and audience participation to the historical material.
- The visit is short and easy to fit into a day, with admission, mobile ticketing, and free parking on site.
- It works best for families and history fans, but some jokes and role-play can feel too broad if you want a quiet museum visit.
Entering St. Augustine’s Old Jail

The Old Jail Museum sits at 167 San Marco Avenue, a short and simple stop for anyone exploring St. Augustine. The building served as the St. Johns County jail for nearly 60 years, holding people until 1953. That gives the tour a useful time frame: this is not a colonial fort or an atmospheric ruin, but a functioning jail from a much more recent chapter of the city’s past.
I find that distinction important. St. Augustine is famous for Spanish-era buildings, stone walls, and early American history. The Old Jail shows another side of the city, one involving petty thieves, accused murderers, prison labor, family life, and the hard rules of local law.
The tour lasts about 30 minutes, so you are not committing half a day. That makes it easy to pair with other sights along San Marco Avenue. Tours begin at 9:00 a.m. and leave about every 20 minutes, continuing through the day until the attraction closes at 4:30 p.m.
The attraction is operated by Historic Tours of America. The presentation is guided rather than a simple walk through empty rooms, and the guide sets the tone from the start. Some guides use a playful prison character, bring visitors into the story, and select people for bits of role-play. Others may present the material in a more measured way.
More Museum Tours in St Augustine:
- Medieval Torture Museum with Ghost Hunting and Tiny Art Gallery
★ 5.0 · 2,011 reviews - St. Augustine: Hop-on Hop-off Trolley Tour with Museum Entry
★ 4.6 · 970 reviews - NYC: 9/11 Memorial & Museum Timed-Entry Ticket
★ 4.8 · 31,428 reviews
Cell blocks, maximum security, and regular prisoners

Inside, you see both the maximum security area and the regular cells. That difference helps you understand that the jail was not one uniform room filled with criminals. It had separate spaces for different kinds of prisoners, including petty offenders and hardened criminals.
The physical setting is the main reason to come. Reading about old jails can feel distant. Here, you can look directly into the cell blocks and see the cramped arrangement that shaped daily life. The experience is not designed as a long scholarly exhibit, but it gives you a clear sense of confinement and control.
The tour also deals with the people held there. You hear accounts of notorious criminals and learn about specific cases, including Sim Jackson, who was hanged in 1908 after murdering his wife with a straight razor. The detail is grim, but it gives the building a human scale. This was not only a place where laws were enforced. It was where real people lost their freedom, faced harsh treatment, and, in some cases, died.
The Old Jail recorded eight executions. Two involved people accused of murder. The gallows are therefore more than a dramatic photo stop. They are part of the jail’s actual record, and the guide explains how executions were carried out there.
I appreciate that the tour can be entertaining without making the subject harmless. Several accounts describe the stories as sobering, even when the guide was funny. That balance matters. You may laugh at a guide’s delivery, then be reminded that the conditions being described were no joke for the people who lived through them.
Sheriff Perry and the power behind the jail

One of the strongest sections centers on Sheriff Perry, who served from 1889 to 1897 and again from 1901 to 1919. He was described as a big, bold man, standing 6 feet 6 inches tall and weighing 300 pounds. Even without the dramatic presentation, that is an imposing figure to place at the head of a small jail.
Perry was popular in the community but feared by the people in his cells. The tour connects his reputation to the prisoner leasing system, in which inmates could be rented to local farmers for labor. That detail changes the way you look at the jail. The building was not simply a place to lock people away. It was part of a wider system of punishment and forced work.
You will hear about male and female prisoners, local crime, and the way authority operated inside the jail. The guide’s job is to keep these details moving quickly, since the whole visit lasts only half an hour. If you want a long discussion of prison reform, legal history, or the economics of inmate labor, this will feel brief. If you want a sharp introduction to the subject, it does the job well.
The stories about Sheriff Perry also give the tour a clear character. Instead of presenting a list of dates, the guide can show you how one powerful sheriff shaped the jail’s reputation. That is one reason the strongest guides receive so much praise. Benny, Patrick, Clarence T., Walter, Louis, Jed, and Bobalew are all singled out for making the material easy to follow and fun for different age groups.
The sheriff’s quarters are part of the story

The Old Jail’s most unusual feature may be the living space upstairs. The sheriff, his wife, and their children lived only a few steps from the prisoners. You can see the sheriff’s quarters and learn how the family’s kitchen was used to prepare meals for the inmates.
That arrangement makes the jail feel less like an isolated public building and more like a workplace combined with a home. Imagine trying to raise children upstairs while prisoners were held below. The layout says a great deal about how jail work once operated, long before modern security systems and strict separation between personal and professional life.
For me, this is more revealing than another display of old bars. The quarters show the jail as a complete social system. Prisoners were below, the sheriff’s family was above, and daily routines connected the two spaces.
You should pay attention here if you are interested in ordinary details. The kitchen, the family rooms, and the closeness of the living quarters help explain how food, supervision, and authority worked. The site’s history is not only about criminals and executions. It is also about the people who ran the facility and lived beside it.
A few more options to weigh up in St Augustine
- St. Augustine Hop-On Hop-Off Trolley Tour
★ 4.5 · 3,799 reviews - St. Augustine Ghost Tour: A Ghostly Encounter
★ 4.5 · 2,404 reviews - Take a Scenic Boat Ride in St. Augustine
★ 4.5 · 1,399 reviews - St. Augustine’s Wine, Cocktail and Food Experience
★ 5.0 · 1,251 reviews
A theatrical guide can make or break the visit

The most praised feature is the guide. The best performances mix clear facts with jokes, character work, and audience participation. Families especially enjoy being pulled into the story. One child-focused account describes a visitor being placed in the birdcage, while other tours have used selected participants to act as temporary inmates.
Benny receives repeated praise for his humor and energy. Patrick is praised for both his delivery and his grasp of the jail’s past. Clarence T. is remembered for explaining details such as the origin of the term jail bird and the old joke involving 239 beans. Jed is described as making the experience fun while still knowing the material. Louis reportedly stayed in character in a way that worked well for children.
Those details are useful because they tell you what sort of attraction this is. You are not walking through a silent building with a printed guide. You are joining a short performance that uses the jail as a stage.
That style works especially well for children, families, and anyone who learns better through stories. It can also make a difficult subject less intimidating. Still, the theatrical approach has a limit. One account describes a guide who used insults such as four eyes and bald-e-locks toward people in the group. The complaint was not about role-play itself, but about failing to judge the mood.
So I would set your expectations carefully. You may get a wonderfully funny guide, a serious storyteller, or a performer whose style is a little too loud. The historical setting remains worthwhile, but the personality of the guide has a real effect on the visit.
Why the $18.09 admission can be worthwhile

At $18.09 per person, the Old Jail is not an all-day attraction. You are paying for about 30 minutes of guided history, not a large museum complex with hours of galleries. That makes the value depend on how well the stop fits your day.
I think the price works if you want a compact, distinctive experience in St. Augustine. You get direct entry with a mobile ticket, admission to the Old Jail, and a guided look at cells, gallows, and living quarters. Children age 5 and younger are free, which improves the value for families with small children.
The attraction also has free parking on site, a useful advantage in a city where parking can complicate a short visit. One less satisfied account reported difficulty finding parking without paying, so I would confirm the current parking arrangement when you arrive rather than count on every nearby space being free.
The strongest value comes from combining this stop with other nearby sightseeing. Since the tour is short and departures are frequent, you can fit it between larger attractions, lunch, or a walk through the historic district. The short format is a benefit if your group includes children who lose interest during long tours.
It is less compelling if you prefer to explore at your own pace. The guided format moves quickly, and the 30-minute schedule leaves little time for lingering over every room. You are buying a lively introduction, not a slow museum study.
Timing, tickets, and a practical visit plan

The Old Jail is open daily from 9:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Guided tours leave every 20 minutes, beginning at 9:00 a.m. Reservations are not accepted, and tours operate first come, first served on the day of your visit.
That point deserves attention. A mobile ticket gives you direct entry without exchanging it for another ticket, but it does not mean you have a reserved time slot. Arrive with enough flexibility to wait for the next departure if the first one is full.
The site is near public transportation, and most people can take part. Service animals are allowed. Transportation to and from the attraction, food, and drinks are not included, so plan those separately.
The attraction closes on Christmas Day. Cancellation is free up to 24 hours before the experience begins, with a full refund. Cancellations or changes made within 24 hours are not refunded or accepted.
Who will enjoy this short history tour

I would recommend the Old Jail to families, first-time visitors to St. Augustine, and anyone who enjoys local history with a little theater. Children often respond well to the role-play, wax figures, jokes, and chances to become part of the story. The guide can turn a plain-looking building into an active scene.
It also suits adults who want a quick look at the darker side of the city. The material covers crime, executions, prison labor, and harsh living conditions, so it is not purely light entertainment. The short length keeps the subject from becoming exhausting.
You may want to skip it if you dislike audience participation or broad character humor. The tour’s history is serious, but the delivery can be playful. Someone looking for a quiet, self-guided examination of jail architecture may prefer a different stop.
I would also think about young children who may be sensitive to stories about murder and executions. The presentation is family-friendly in tone, but the subject matter itself can be unsettling. You know your group best.
Should you book the Old Jail Museum?
I would book it if you want a short, unusual stop that adds social history to a day of sightseeing. The cells, gallows, Sheriff Perry’s story, and upstairs family quarters give you details you will not get from a standard walk through St. Augustine’s historic center.
The best reason to go is the combination of a genuine historic setting and a lively guide. The biggest caution is the same thing: the performance style varies. Arrive ready for humor, audience involvement, and a fast-moving presentation, and you are likely to get good value from the $18.09 admission.
If your schedule is tight, this is an easy yes. If you prefer quiet museums and dislike being called into the action, think twice. For most families and history-minded visitors, the Old Jail earns its place on the list, especially when you have half an hour to spare.
FAQ
How long does the Old Jail Museum tour take?
The guided experience lasts approximately 30 minutes.
What are the Old Jail Museum’s hours?
The attraction is open daily from 9:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. It is closed on Christmas Day.
How often do tours depart?
Guided tours depart every 20 minutes, beginning at 9:00 a.m.
Can I reserve a specific tour time?
No. Reservations are not accepted, and tours operate on a first come, first served basis on the day of your visit.
Is parking available?
Yes. Free parking is available on site. Transportation to and from the attraction is not included.
What is the cancellation policy?
You can cancel at least 24 hours before the start time for a full refund. Cancellations or changes made less than 24 hours before the start time are not accepted, and the amount paid is not refunded.
Just added in St Augustine
- Walking History Tour of St. Augustine’s Historic District★ 5.0 · 1,152 reviews
- Wine Tasting Cruise in St. Augustine★ 5.0 · 426 reviews
- The Original Haunted Pub Tour★ 4.5 · 382 reviews
- St. Augustine’s Wine, Cocktail and Food Experience★ 5.0 · 1,251 reviews
- Private Guided Historic Electric Cart Tour of St. Augustine★ 5.0 · 1,194 reviews
- Sunset Cruise of St. Augustine★ 5.0 · 1,235 reviews
- Nights of Lights Boat Cruise★ 4.5 · 382 reviews
- St. Augustine Live Music Cruise with Drinks and Sunset Option★ 5.0 · 315 reviews
Museums, compared.

Empire State Building Tickets – Observatory & Museum
Read our review →
9/11 Memorial, Ground Zero Tour with Optional 9/11 Museum Ticket
Read our review →
All-Access 9/11: Ground Zero Tour, Memorial and Museum, One World Observatory
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in





